Nov 18, 20265 min read

GitHub Actions vs GitLab CI/CD

How GitHub Actions and GitLab CI/CD compare on pipeline syntax, runners, included minutes and per-minute prices, reuse, secrets and cloud deploys with OIDC, with the same build-test-deploy pipeline written for both.

Illustration for GitHub Actions vs GitLab CI/CD

GitHub Actions and GitLab CI/CD both run YAML-defined jobs on every push, and the choice usually follows where the code already lives. The differences are in how pipelines are reused across repositories, what runner minutes cost, and how much YAML it takes to deploy a backend to AWS or GCP.

This comparison covers syntax, runners and pricing, reuse and cloud credentials, with the same pipeline written for both. It ends with Encore, where the deploy step to your own AWS or GCP account is part of the push instead of a pipeline you maintain.

GitHub Actions vs GitLab CI/CD at a glance

GitHub ActionsGitLab CI/CD
Config file.github/workflows/*.yml, many workflows per repoOne .gitlab-ci.yml, plus includes
StructureWorkflows of jobs, ordered with needsStages of jobs, or a DAG with needs
ReuseMarketplace actions, reusable workflowsinclude, templates, CI/CD components and catalog
Hosted runnersLinux, Windows, macOS, arm64, larger runnersLinux, Windows, macOS on GitLab.com
Self-hosted runnersFree to run, Actions Runner Controller for KubernetesGitLab Runner, free to run
Included usage$12 a month on Free, $18 on Team400 compute minutes on Free, 10,000 on Premium
Linux price$0.006 per minute, 2-core x64Additional compute minutes bought in packs
OIDC to cloudsid-token: write and provider actionsid_tokens with an aud value
Self-managed platformGitHub Enterprise ServerGitLab Self-Managed, including the Free tier

Prices come from GitHub's Actions runner pricing, the GitHub Actions billing docs and GitLab's pricing page, checked on November 18, 2026. GitHub's included usage is a dollar amount drawn down by runner minutes and storage, so $12 covers 2,000 minutes on the standard Linux runner.

The same pipeline on both

A Go service that runs tests and then deploys a container image to AWS through OIDC looks like this in GitHub Actions:

# .github/workflows/deploy.yml name: deploy on: push: branches: [main] permissions: id-token: write contents: read jobs: test: runs-on: ubuntu-latest steps: - uses: actions/checkout@v4 - uses: actions/setup-go@v5 with: go-version: "1.26" - run: go test ./... deploy: needs: test runs-on: ubuntu-latest steps: - uses: actions/checkout@v4 - uses: aws-actions/configure-aws-credentials@v4 with: role-to-assume: arn:aws:iam::123456789012:role/github-deploy aws-region: eu-west-1 - run: ./scripts/deploy.sh

The same pipeline in GitLab CI/CD uses stages and an ID token that the job exchanges for AWS credentials itself:

# .gitlab-ci.yml stages: [test, deploy] test: stage: test image: golang:1.26 script: - go test ./... deploy: stage: deploy image: amazon/aws-cli:latest rules: - if: $CI_COMMIT_BRANCH == "main" id_tokens: AWS_ID_TOKEN: aud: sts.amazonaws.com script: - > export $(printf "AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID=%s AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY=%s AWS_SESSION_TOKEN=%s" $(aws sts assume-role-with-web-identity --role-arn arn:aws:iam::123456789012:role/gitlab-deploy --role-session-name "gitlab-$CI_PIPELINE_ID" --web-identity-token "$AWS_ID_TOKEN" --duration-seconds 3600 --query 'Credentials.[AccessKeyId,SecretAccessKey,SessionToken]' --output text)) - ./scripts/deploy.sh

Both rely on an IAM role that trusts the provider's OIDC issuer, token.actions.githubusercontent.com or gitlab.com, restricted to the repository and branch in the trust policy's sub condition. The guide to deploying from GitHub Actions to AWS without long-lived keys covers that trust policy in detail. What is left out of both is deploy.sh, which is where the image build, the ECS task definition update and the database migration live.

Reuse across repositories

GitHub's model is many small units: Marketplace actions such as actions/setup-go, and reusable workflows called with uses: org/repo/.github/workflows/deploy.yml@v1. The ecosystem is large, which also means pinning third-party actions to a commit SHA, since an action runs with the job's token. GitLab's model is composition: include pulls in YAML from other projects or templates, and CI/CD components add versioned inputs and a catalog, so a platform team can publish one deploy component that every service includes.

Runners and cost

On GitHub, the standard Linux 2-core x64 runner is $0.006 per minute, arm64 is $0.005, Windows is $0.010 and macOS is $0.062, and self-hosted runners stay free. On GitLab.com, Free includes 400 compute minutes a month and Premium includes 10,000, with more minutes sold as add-on packs, and self-managed GitLab Runner costs nothing beyond the machines. For a backend with a five-minute test suite and 40 pushes a working day, that is about 4,000 Linux minutes a month, which fits Premium's quota on GitLab and costs roughly $12 beyond the included amount on GitHub Free.

How does Encore change the deploy step?

Encore

In both pipelines above, the deploy job is the part you write and maintain, together with the IAM role and the Terraform behind it. Encore brings infrastructure from code, so the databases, queues and buckets are declared in the Go or TypeScript application, and pushing to the connected GitHub repository, or to Encore's own git remote, starts a build and test phase, an infrastructure provisioning phase and a deploy phase in your AWS or GCP account, as the deploy docs describe. Encore provisions an IAM role for the service, or a service account on GCP.

Application code passes through Encore and infrastructure guardrails to resources provisioned in your own AWS or GCP account.
Get started
brew install encoredev/tap/encore &&
encore app create
Copy

Run in your terminal to get started locally.

// encore.app { "id": "acme-backend", "build": { "hooks": { // Runs after dependencies are fetched, before the Encore build. "prebuild": "go generate ./...", // Runs after the Encore build has finished. "postbuild": "echo build done" } } }

Build hooks in encore.app cover the custom steps that would otherwise sit in a CI job, and deploys can also be triggered through Encore's API, which is how a GitLab pipeline or any other CI hands off to Encore after its own checks. You can keep GitHub Actions or GitLab CI for linting, security scans and anything else, without a deploy job in either.

A coding agent that adds a queue or a bucket in the code does not also edit a pipeline or a Terraform module, since the same push that ships the code provisions what it declares.

Best fit: Go or TypeScript backends on AWS or GCP that want deploys and infrastructure provisioning to follow a git push, with CI left for checks.

How to choose

Pick GitHub Actions when the code lives on GitHub and you want the Marketplace, cheap per-minute Linux runners and reusable workflows. Pick GitLab CI/CD when you want source, CI, registry and environments in one product, a self-managed install, or stage-based pipelines shared as components. Pick Encore when the pipeline mostly exists to deploy a backend to AWS or GCP, so that deploy becomes part of the push.

Frequently asked questions

Is GitHub Actions better than GitLab CI?

No. Neither wins everywhere: GitHub Actions wins when the code is on GitHub, thanks to the Marketplace of reusable actions and per-minute hosted runner pricing. GitLab CI/CD wins when you want one product for source, CI, registry and environments, or need to self-manage the whole platform, and its stage-based YAML is easier to read for long pipelines.

How many free CI minutes do GitHub and GitLab include?

GitHub now expresses included Actions usage as money: $12 a month on GitHub Free, enough for 2,000 minutes on the standard Linux 2-core runner at $0.006 per minute. GitLab Free includes 400 compute minutes a month, and Premium at $29 per user per month includes 10,000. Both checked on November 18, 2026.

Can GitHub Actions and GitLab CI deploy to AWS without access keys?

Yes. Both issue OIDC tokens to jobs. In GitHub Actions you grant id-token: write and use aws-actions/configure-aws-credentials with a role ARN, and in GitLab CI you declare id_tokens with an aud value and exchange the token with aws sts assume-role-with-web-identity. The AWS IAM role trusts the provider's OIDC issuer instead of storing long-lived keys.

Do I need GitHub Actions or GitLab CI to deploy an Encore app?

No. Pushing to the connected GitHub repository or to Encore's git remote starts a build and test phase, an infrastructure provisioning phase and a deploy phase in your AWS or GCP account. You can keep your existing CI for linting and other checks, or trigger deploys through Encore's API.

Deploy to your cloud on AWS and Google Cloud
without managing infrastructure

Encore lets developers and agents define application infrastructure directly in code, then automatically provisions it from local development to production in your AWS or GCP account.

~/orders — claude
Claude Code
Claude Code v2.1.180Opus 5.5~/orders